| RK | PLAYER | POS | HOMETOWN | HT | WT | STARS | GRADE | SCHOOL |
| 1 | SG | Brookville, NY Long Island Lutheran High School | 6'4'' | 185 | 96 |  Baylor Committed 01/14/2024 | ||
| 2 | SF | Bronx, NY Our Savior Lutheran High School | 6'4'' | 180 | 93 |  N Carolina Signed | ||
| 3 | PG | White Plains, NY Archbishop Stepinac High School | 6'2'' | 175 | 91 |  Arkansas Committed 04/25/2024 | ||
| 4 | PG | Bronx, NY Our Savior Lutheran High School | 6'1'' | 170 | 84 |  Miss. St Signed | ||
| 5 | SF | Middle Village, NY Christ the King High School | 6'4'' | 200 | 82 |  Iowa State Signed | ||
| 6 | SG | Bronx, NY Our Savior Lutheran High School | 6'4'' | 175 | 82 |  Syracuse Signed | ||
| 7 | C | New Rochelle, NY Long Island Lutheran High School | 6'9'' | 210 | 81 |  Seton Hall Signed | ||
| 8 | PF | Middle Island, NY Christ the King High School | 6'8'' | 220 | 81 | |||
| 9 | PG | Bronx, NY Cardinal Hayes High School | 6'1'' | 175 | 79 |  Iona Committed | ||
| 10 | C | Bronx, NY La Lumiere School | 6'10'' | 235 | 80 | |||
| 11 | SF | Brooklyn, NY South Shore High School | 6'4'' | 185 | 78 | |||
| 12 | SG | Staten Island, NY Curtis High School | 6'4'' | 78 | ||||
| 13 | SF | Bronx, NY Our Savior Lutheran High School | 6'6'' | 78 | ||||
| 14 | PF | White Plains, NY Archbishop Stepinac High School | 6'8'' | 200 | 78 |  Quinnipiac Committed 02/07/2024 | ||
| 15 | C | Middle Island, NY Christ the King High School | 6'7'' | 220 | 76 | |||
| 16 | C | White Plains, NY South Kent School | 6'7'' | 220 | 76 |
