| Ilja Dragunov | 9/30/23 | No Mercy | TBD | 1 |
| Carmelo Hayes | 4/1/23 | Stand & Deliver | 182 days | 1 |
| Bron Breakker | 4/4/22 | Raw | 362 days | 2 |
| Dolph Ziggler | 3/8/22 | NXT Roadblock | 27 days | 1 |
| Bron Breakker | 1/4/22 | NXT New Year's Evil | 63 days | 1 |
| Tommaso Ciampa | 9/14/21 | NXT 2.0 TV | 112 days | 2 |
| ^Vacant | 9/12/21 | N/A | N/A | N/A |
| Samoa Joe | 8/22/21 | NXT TakeOver 36 | 21 days | 3 |
| Karrion Kross | 4/8/20 | NXT TakeOver: Stand & Deliver | 136 days | 2 |
| Finn Balor | 9/8/20 | NXT Super Tuesday II | 212 days | 2 |
| +Vacant | 8/26/20 | NXT TV | N/A | N/A |
| Karrion Kross | 8/22/20 | NXT TakeOver; XXX | 3 days | 1 |
| Keith Lee | 7/8/20 | NXT's Great American Bash (Night 2) | 44 days | 1 |
| Adam Cole | 6/1/19 | NXT TakeOver: XXV | 403 days | 1 |
| Johnny Gargano | 4/5/19 | NXT TakeOver: New York | 57 days | 1 |
| *Vacant | 3/13/19 | NXT TV | N/A | N/A |
| Tommaso Ciampa | 8/18/18 | NXT TV | 238 days | 1 |
| Aleister Black | 4/7/18 | NXT TakeOver: New Orleans | 102 days | 1 |
| Andrade 'Cien' Almas | 11/18/17 | NXT TakeOver: War Games | 140 days | 1 |
| Drew McIntyre | 8/19/17 | NXT TakeOver: Brooklyn III | 91 days | 1 |
| Bobby Roode | 1/29/17 | NXT TakeOver: San Antonio | 203 days | 1 |
| Shinsuke Nakamura | 12/3/16 | NXT Live: Osaka | 56 days | 2 |
| Samoa Joe | 11/19/16 | NXT TakeOver: Toronto | 14 days | 2 |
| Shinsuke Nakamura | 8/20/16 | NXT TakeOver: Brooklyn II | 91 days | 1 |
| Samoa Joe | 4/21/16 | NXT Live: Lowell - Lowell, MA | 121 days | 1 |
| Finn Balor | 7/4/15 | Beast in the East | 292 days | 1 |
| Kevin Owens | 2/11/15 | NXT TakeOver: Rival | 143 days | 1 |
| Sami Zayn | 12/11/14 | NXT TakeOver: R Evolution | 62 days | 1 |
| Neville | 2/27/14 | NXT ArRIVAL | 287 days | 1 |
| Bo Dallas | 6/12/13 | NXT | 260 days | 1 |
| Big E | 1/9/13 | NXT | 154 days | 1 |
| Seth Rollins | 8/29/12 | NXT | 133 days | 1 |
