| RK | PLAYER | POS | HOMETOWN | HT | WT | STARS | GRADE | SCHOOL |
| 1 | WR | New Haven, IN New Haven High School | 6'1'' | 170 | 86 |  Ohio State Signed | ||
| 2 | WR | Nappanee, IN Northwood High School | 6'1'' | 195 | 83 |  Georgia Signed | ||
| 3 | OT | New Palestine, IN New Palestine High School | 6'6'' | 300 | 83 | Ohio State Signed | ||
| 4 | ATH | Fort Wayne, IN North Side High School | 6'3'' | 175 | 81 |  Notre Dame Signed | ||
| 5 | CB | Nappanee, IN Northwood High School | 6'1'' | 185 | 80 |  Michigan Signed | ||
| 6 | OT | Fishers, IN Hamilton Southeastern High School | 6'6'' | 280 | 80 | Notre Dame Signed | ||
| 7 | QB-PP | Greenwood, IN Center Grove High School | 6'4'' | 205 | 79 |  Indiana Signed | ||
| 8 | CB | Carmel, IN Carmel High School | 5'11'' | 185 | 78 | Indiana Committed 06/06/2023 | ||
| 9 | QB-PP | Indianapolis, IN Cathedral High School | 6'1'' | 195 | 78 |  San Diego St Signed | ||
| 10 | ILB | Indianapolis, IN Ben Davis High School | 5'11'' | 220 | 77 |  Kent State Signed | ||
| 11 | RB | Michigan City, IN Michigan City High School | 5'11'' | 190 | 77 |  Syracuse Signed | ||
| 12 | OG | Speedway, IN Speedway High School | 6'4'' | 275 | 77 | Indiana Signed | ||
| 13 | CB | Indianapolis, IN Franklin Central High School | 6'2'' | 190 | 77 |  Purdue Signed | ||
| 14 | TE-Y | Greenfield, IN Greenfield Central High School | 6'5'' | 245 | 76 |  Georgia St Signed | ||
| 15 | WR | Fishers, IN Hamilton Southeastern High School | 6'3'' | 190 | 76 | Purdue Signed | ||
| 16 | OT | Noblesville, IN Noblesville High School | 6'7'' | 295 | 76 |  Louisville Signed | ||
| 17 | RB | Saint John, IN Lake Central High School | 6'0'' | 220 | 76 |  Iowa Signed | ||
| 18 | WR | Brownsburg, IN Brownsburg High School | 6'1'' | 175 | 76 |  Tulsa Signed | ||
| 19 | DE | Peru, IN Peru High School | 6'3'' | 235 | 75 |  Nrthwestrn Signed | ||
| 20 | OT | Valparaiso, IN Valparaiso High School | 6'5'' | 275 | 75 |  Toledo Signed | ||
| 21 | QB-PP | Fairland, IN Triton Central High School | 6'2'' | 185 | 75 |  E Michigan Signed | ||
| 22 | TE-Y | Bloomington, IN Bloomington North High School | 6'5'' | 245 | 75 |  Marshall Signed | ||
| 23 | OG | Fort Wayne, IN North Side High School | 6'5'' | 310 | 75 | Purdue Signed | ||
| 24 | OT | Danville, IN Danville Community High School | 6'6'' | 250 | 75 | Indiana Signed | ||
| 25 | WR | Leo, IN Leo Junior Senior High School | 5'11'' | 180 | 74 |  Ohio Signed | ||
| 26 | TE-H | Indianapolis, IN Cathedral High School | 6'6'' | 220 | 74 |  Miami (OH) Signed | ||
| 27 | RB | Fishers, IN Fishers High School | 6'0'' | 200 | 74 | Indiana Signed | ||
| 28 | ATH | Saint Leon, IN East Central High School | 6'1'' | 195 | 74 | Miami (OH) Signed | ||
| 29 | K | Brownsburg, IN Brownsburg High School | 5'11'' | 185 | 74 | Purdue Signed | ||
| 30 | TE-Y | Bloomington, IN Bloomington South High School | 6'3'' | 225 | 74 | Toledo Signed | ||
| 31 | S | Crown Point, IN Crown Point High School | 6'2'' | 185 | 73 | Toledo Signed | ||
| 32 | S | Fort Wayne, IN Carroll High School | 5'11'' | 185 | 73 |  W Michigan Signed | ||
| 33 | OT | Avon, IN Avon High School | 6'5'' | 270 | 72 |  Ball State Signed | ||
| 34 | QB-PP | Avon, IN Avon High School | 6'1'' | 215 | 72 | W Michigan Signed | ||
| 35 | QB-PP | Indianapolis, IN Ben Davis High School | 6'1'' | 190 | 72 | Miami (OH) Signed | ||
| 36 | OG | Brownsburg, IN Brownsburg High School | 6'4'' | 300 | 70 | W Michigan Signed |
