Villanova (6-0, 3-0 Colonial Athletic Association), ranked No. 5 in the STATS FCS Top 25, had its hands full with the upset-minded Tribe (2-4, 0-2).
Kilton Anderson staked William & Mary to a 7-0 lead with a 12-yard TD pass to Kane Everson, capping a 12-play, 77-yard game-opening drive. After forcing a Villanova punt, the Tribe turned the ball over on their first play from scrimmage when Drew Wiley forced an Everson fumble after a catch and Nowooola Awopetu returned it eight yards to the William & Mary 17-yard line. Two plays later Justin Covington scored on a 3-yard run to knot the score at 7.
The Wildcats took advantage of a 22-yard punt by Will Michael to grab a 14-7 lead, scoring on Smith's 16-yard toss to Jaaron Hayek. Villanova stretched its lead to 21-7 on Barlee's 15-yard TD run, but Anderson connected with Zach Burdick for a 16-yard score sandwiched around a pair of missed field goals by Villanova's Drew Kresge and the Tribe trailed 21-14 at halftime.
William & Mary knotted the score at 21, using a marathon 17-play drive that covered 76 yards and took 7:36 off the clock with Bronson Yoder scoring on a 2-yard run.
Villanova recaptured the lead at 28-21 when Smith hooked up with Hayek for a 37-yard score, but Anderson again pulled the Tribe even when he hit Everson for a 20-yard TD on fourth-and-1 with 9:56 remaining in the game.
The Wildcats took the lead for good with a 16-play drive that took nearly 8 minutes off the clock.
The Tribe drove to the Villanova 30-yard line before turning the ball over on downs.
Smith completed 21 of 34 passes for 250 yards and three TDs for the Wildcats. Anderson finished 25-of-33 passing for 245 yards and three scores. Everson caught 11 passes for 131 yards and two touchdowns.
College football recruiting: Which teams are overperforming and which are underperforming?
When it comes to college football's 2022 recruiting class, which teams are exceeding expectations and which schools aren't meeting their standards?
The biggest challenges facing each new college football coach
Whether they like it or not, each new college football hire inherits obstacles. We take a look at the biggest challenges facing the 18 new head-coaching hires ahead of the 2021 season.
NCAA recommends routine COVID-19 tests for unvaccinated athletes in latest guidance report
Unvaccinated athletes should be tested weekly for COVID-19, wear masks, and be quarantined if exposed to the virus, while vaccinated individuals should not be tested routinely, according to the NCAA's safety recommendations released on Wednesday.
Oregon DBs Jamal Hill, DJ James charged after three report being shot with airsoft gun
Oregon defensive backs Jamal Hill and DJ James are both facing multiple charges after three people reported being shot at with an airsoft gun.
Ex-Penn State president Graham Spanier released from jail after two months
Graham Spanier, the former president of Penn State, was released Wednesday after serving 58 days in prison for endangering the welfare of children by his response in the Jerry Sandusky case.
After Texas announces Big 12 departure, AD Chris Del Conte comes off College Football Playoff selection committee
Kansas State athletic director Gene Taylor has been added to the College Football Playoff selection committee, replacing Texas AD Chris Del Conte.