The Mariners, coming off a blown late lead and a 10-inning loss on Saturday, had to deal with more bad news two batters into the game when Haniger fouled a pitch off his left knee and had to be helped from the field.
Mariners manager Scott Servais said X-rays showed a deep bone bruise and Haniger will likely have more tests on Monday with the team back in Seattle. The injury is another setback for the Mariners, who have used a major-league high 51 players this season. Haniger leads the team in homers and RBI.
J.P. Crawford, who singled and stole second to begin the game, had a clear view of Haniger's at-bat.
“I just knew,” Crawford said. “It didn't look good. I felt bad for him, but we need him. Hopefully he gets back sooner than later.”
Fraley completed the at-bat with a strikeout and flied out in the second, but his two-run homer in the fourth pushed Seattle's lead to 5-0. Kyle Seager hit a solo homer in the third off Bieber, who gave up five runs in 5 2/3 innings.
Seattle has beaten Bieber twice this season, scoring eight runs on 15 hits in 10 1/3 innings, but Seager doesn't believe the Mariners have figured him out.
“He's a tough pitcher,” Seager said. “The curveball is so tight. It's so hard. He's that good for a reason. We had some really good at-bats. We really battled him and worked. It was a good offensive performance by us.”
Bieber (7-4) gave up 10 hits, struck out eight and walked two. He retired the side in order only once and threw 107 pitches.
“Today, I got beat for not executing,” Bieber said. “That’s obvious. Whether it’s curveball, fastball, slider, changeup, cutter, it doesn’t really matter. I just got to be better and continue to hit spots, execute throughout the game, strike one, two and three and then continue momentum.”
Bieber and Aaron Civale have had to carry the load for Cleveland’s rotation, which has been plagued by injuries and inexperience.
The Indians optioned right-hander Triston McKenzie to Triple-A Columbus before the game. Zach Plesac, who sustained a broken right thumb after angrily removing his shirt following a rough outing, is playing catch but there's no timetable for his return.
Servais said Saturday's 5-4 loss — in which closer Rafael Montero couldn't hold a 4-1 lead after retiring the first two batters in the ninth — left a sour taste in his mouth. Gilbert's strong outing and the home runs were much sweeter.
“To go out there and shut them down like he did is exactly what we needed,” Servais said.
José Godoy and Crawford had run-scoring singles in the second for Seattle, which went 4-6 on an 11-day trip. Crawford and Seager each had three hits while Jake Bauers, acquired from Cleveland on Thursday, had two hits and an RBI.
Amed Rosario had an RBI single in the sixth for Cleveland. The Indians loaded the bases with two outs in the ninth off Kendall Graveman and scored a run on a wild pitch, but Josh Naylor lined to Fraley in left field to end the game.
Graveman was making his second appearance since being activated after a COVID-19 scare.
Haniger, who has 16 home runs and 40 RBI, was struck squarely on the knee by the foul ball and went to the ground immediately. He slowly got to his feet and was assisted off the field by Servais and a trainer.
Indians: OF Jordan Luplow is still bothered by a sprained left ankle, ending his rehab assignment at Triple-A Columbus. President of baseball operations Chris Antonetti said Luplow will be rechecked by doctors and could get another opinion. Luplow has been on the injured list since May 28.
Mariners: LHP Marco Gonzales (1-4, 5.45 ERA) will start the opener of a three-game home series against Minnesota on Monday night.
Indians: RHP J.C. Mejia (1-1, 4.15) will pitch the opener on Monday night as Cleveland welcomes Baltimore for a four-game series.
Mariners win on another wild pitch again against A's
— Struggling rookie Jarred Kelenic scored the winning run on Lou Trivino’s wild pitch in the bottom of the ninth, Mitch Haniger homered twice and the Seattle Mariners beat the Oakland Athletics 5-4 on Saturday night.
Wild pitch sends Mariners to walk-off win
Lou Trivino's wild pitch allows Jarred Kelenic to score as the Mariners beat the Athletics 5-4 in walk-off fashion.
Polanco, Newman lead Pirates to 10-2 romp over Giants
— Gregory Polanco homered, drove in three runs and scored twice, and Kevin Newman matched his career high with four hits for the Pittsburgh Pirates, who beat the NL West-leading San Francisco Giants 10-2 Saturday night.
Gregory Polanco's 426-foot long ball helps Pirates top Giants
Gregory Polanco hits his 11th home run of the season as part of the Pirates' win vs. the Giants.
Yoan Moncada missing home plate proves costly for White Sox
Yoan Moncada fails to step on home on a play at the plate, and the White Sox have their run taken off the board after a replay review.
Barnes HR, Jansen bounces back as Dodgers edge Rockies 1-0
— Austin Barnes homered early, Kenley Jansen preserved the lead late and the Los Angeles Dodgers snapped a three-game losing streak with a 1-0 victory over the Colorado Rockies on Saturday night.