<
        >
          24/09 - 12:30 PM BST
          3rd ODI, Australia tour of England at Chester-le-Street, Sep 24 2024
          24/09 - 12:30 PM BST
          3rd ODI, Australia tour of England at Chester-le-Street, Sep 24 2024

          England search for answers against impressive world champions

          play
          The Huddle: Smith recalls his battle with Archer in Ashes 2019 (4:07)

          "He hit me pretty flush in the head but I don't remember it hurting that much, strangely" (4:07)

          • Andrew McGlashan, Deputy editor, ESPNcricinfoSep 23, 2024, 02:08 PM
            Close
              Deputy Editor Andrew arrived at ESPNcricinfo via Manchester and Cape Town, after finding the assistant editor at a weak moment as he watched England's batting collapse in the Newlands Test. Andrew began his cricket writing as a freelance covering Lancashire during 2004 when they were relegated in the County Championship. In fact, they were top of the table when he began reporting on them but things went dramatically downhill. He likes to let people know that he is a supporter of county cricket, a fact his colleagues will testify to and bemoan in equal quantities.

          Big Picture

          Australia have played like world champions, England have played like a team that has only just come together and are trying to figure out their next style of one-day cricket. Which is exactly the position of both sides.
          What will (or at least should) frustrate Harry Brook and Marcus Trescothick - stand-in captain and coach - is that England have had their opportunity in both games: at Trent Bridge they were 213 for 2 in the 33rd over before falling away to Australia's collection of spinners and at Headingley they had the visitors 161 for 6 and 221 for 9 before Alex Carey swung the momentum.

          In both matches, Australia have found key performances from potentially unlikely sources, firstly with Marnus Labuschagne's three wickets then Carey's superb 74 off 67 balls from an opening that only presented itself due to Josh Inglis' injury.

          With Australia struck down by illness ahead of Trent Bridge, it always felt as though that was going to prove a big missed opportunity for England and so it proved as Mitchell Starc, Josh Hazlewood and Glenn Maxwell returned at Headingley and combined to take 7 for 119. With an eye to the future, Aaron Hardie's performance was also significant with 2 for 26.

          England have some of the building blocks to make their attempts at rejuvenation a success. Ben Duckett is in excellent form, Jamie Smith is a high-class batter whatever colour ball he is facing, Brydon Carse could yet replicate the Liam Plunkett role - even if Carse says it's never been spoken about - Adil Rashid remains world-class (although replacing him is a concern) and there is a collection of quicks with genuine pace.

          However, at the moment they seem unable to quite find their groove, especially with the bat, with Brook's comments about not caring whether batters are caught attempting to clear the boundary not yet carrying the weight of when Eoin Morgan backed his team's ultra-aggressive mantra in 2015. There is time yet for the rebuild to come together; Chester-le-Street would be a good place to start to at least ensure this series remains undecided for a few more days.

          Form guide

          (last five completed matches, most recent first)
          England LLLWL
          Australia WWWWW

          play4:07
          The Huddle: Smith recalls his battle with Archer in Ashes 2019

          "He hit me pretty flush in the head but I don't remember it hurting that much, strangely"

          In the spotlight: Phil Salt and Steven Smith

          Phil Salt appears to have the task of playing the ultra-aggressive opener but he hasn't looked entirely convincing in the first two matches. At Trent Bridge he seemed somewhat perplexed when bowled as he gave himself room against Ben Dwarshuis then at Headingley he was given a working over by Josh Hazlewood. He survived a review for a caught behind and was dropped at slip as he flayed at Hazlewood's relentless short-of-a-length line around off stump before edging through to Carey. He will, no doubt, be fully backed to continue in the same vein but Australia's quick bowlers are not easy to smash off their lengths.
          Back home, Steven Smith is at the centre of the key debate in Australian men's cricket - or at least as much as these things raise attention during the September football final season - about where he will bat when India arrive for the Test series. For now he's been at No. 3 and 4 in this series and would no doubt like a decent score. He looked in good touch in the opening game before offering a return catch to Liam Livingstone then was beaten by a superb delivery from Matthew Potts at Headingley. There is a good chance of a second rematch with Jofra Archer which always makes for compelling viewing.

          Team news: Archer in line for return, Australia hopeful illness has passed

          Archer would appear likely to slot back in having been given his expected rest at Headingley. Who he replaces will be interesting: Olly Stone bowled with good pace in Leeds, Potts was excellent and Carse adds some batting depth at No. 8. England felt potentially a seamer light in the last game, but without a true pace-bowling allrounder it's hard to squeeze another option in.

          England: (possible) 1 Ben Duckett, 2 Phil Salt, 3 Will Jacks, 4 Harry Brook (capt), 5 Jamie Smith (wk), 6 Liam Livingstone, 7 Jacob Bethell, 8 Brydon Carse, 9 Jofra Archer, 10 Adil Rashid, 11 Matthew Potts

          Ben Dwarshuis has flown home after picking up a pectoral injury which restricted him to just four overs on debut in Nottingham. However, other than that Australia are hopeful of having a full squad to select from for the first time in the series. If Inglis is fit it creates an interesting call to make after Carey's success in the last match. Inglis could play as a specialist batter, but there isn't room for that, either, unless there's some rotation. The north of England in September may require an extra pace-bowling option with Cameron Green and Sean Abbott available.

          Australia: (possible) 1 Travis Head, 2 Matthew Short, 3 Mitchell Marsh (capt), 4 Steven Smith, 5 Marnus Labuschagne, 6 Alex Carey (wk), 7 Glenn Maxwell, 8 Aaron Hardie, 9 Mitchell Starc, 10 Josh Hazlewood, 11 Adam Zampa

          Pitch and conditions

          Teams were forced to train indoors on Monday but the forecast for game day is a little better, albeit with the chance of showers. To say it will be mild might be stretching things. Overhead conditions could assist the bowlers although pitches at Chester-le-Street are usually pretty good for batting in one-day cricket.

          Stats and trivia

          • Starc needs one more wicket to move into fourth spot alone in Australia's ODI tally. He equalled Mitchell Johnson on 239 during the previous game.

          • England have two ODI centuries in the XI which played at Trent Bridge - one apiece for Duckett and Salt - while Australia had 28.

          • England have a 3-1 winning record at Chester-le-Street against Australia. In 2018, Aaron Finch and Shaun Marsh struck centuries but England comfortably chased 311 as Jason Roy made 101 off 83 balls. Only three players from that game will likely appear this time: Carey, Travis Head and Adil Rashid

          Quotes

          "There have been big changes, new batters, new bowlers. It will take time. It will always take time when it is a rebuilding process. We have got every base covered in terms of bowling, batting, keeping. Everything is there for us."
          Adil Rashid on England's new era