Essex 266 (Lawrence 105, Roland-Jones 7-61) and 211 (Critchley 53, Murtagh 4-44) beat Middlesex 170 (Higgins 70, Simpson 63, Porter 6-35) and 210 (Hollman 63*, S Cook 3-31, Porter 3-34) by 97 runs
As far as statements of intent go, Essex's 97-run victory over Middlesex in the first match of the 2023 season is loud and clear. The County Champions of 2017 and 2019 - and inaugural winners of the Bob Willis Trophy in 2020 - are as ruthless as ever.
Despite losing the toss and "only" scoring 266 in their first innings, Essex's control of game was never in doubt. Perhaps their only frustration came on this final day when they were made to wait until 2:45pm for the last of the five wickets required.
The final dismissal was Jamie Porter's ninth of the match, with 3 for 34 supplementing 6 for 35 in the first innings. Sam Cook, who took Sunday's first wicket, settled for 3 for 31 (4 for 73 overall, from 33 overs). The opening pair used Dan Lawrence's expertly crafted 105 to dismantle Middlesex's top-order twice - 4 for 4 on day two; 15 for 3 on day three - meaning we arrived here on Easter Sunday under bright skies expecting little beyond an Essex victory.
The last stanza was very much a team effort from the bowlers, with Shane Snater's 2 for 34 and a wicket apiece for Simon Harmer and Matt Critchley last night. But Porter and Cook were the headliners overall and, in this form, rival other new-ball duos in Division One. Skipper Tom Westley was told as much on day four.
"I bumped into Sam Robson at lunchtime, and he was like, 'How easy is it for you with these seamers, and then you've got Simon Harmer?'" said Westley. "It does make it easier, in terms of the personnel you can turn to. The challenging bit is telling them they're not bowling!"
For Porter, this fixture was a welcome return to form. Along with a first five-wicket haul since 2020, the overall 9 for 69 were his best match figures since 11 for 98 against Worcestershire back in September 2018. While urging a degree of caution on an outright return to the 2017-to-2019 vintage, which saw Porter on the cusp of England honours with 199 first-class dismissals across three summers, Westley is pleased by the 29-year-old's re-emergence after a tough couple of seasons.
"I'm so happy for Ports. He's an integral part of our team: when we're doing well, it's coincided with when he's taken wickets. I think he's worked really hard with Mick Lewis, the bowling coach. I think he's made a couple of technical adjustments, but nothing too drastic.
"He's got a little bit wider on the crease, like how he used to be. He's always very awkward to face because of his angles. I also think, for Ports, someone that led the attack for a number of years, with the likes of Sam Cook and Shane Snater coming through, it's going to be a bit challenging going from the main man to one of the bowling unit.
"There's obviously a little bit of the England stuff from a few years ago," said Westley, referencing Porter's elusive Test cap and missing out on the enlarged 55-man training squad during 2020's Covid-19 summer. "When you get so close and don't quite get the chance that sometimes plays on your mind. You want it too much or you chase it too much.
"I think what he's done fantastically well is he's gone back to basics - what made him so successful in those years leading up to 2017 and 2019 - and he's looking to repeat that."
If Middlesex are chastened by such a heavy defeat in their first outing in the top-flight since 2017, they could at least wonder how different things could have been. Luke Hollman's 63 not out, along with Ryan Higgins' 41 and Stevie Eskinazi's 114-ball 37 spoke of the application within the batting. Alas, when your top three only manage a combined 7 for 6 in the match, there is only so much you can do.
The first of the final five wickets came within the 10 minutes of the morning, Cook needing just four deliveries to send the nightwatcher Tom Helm back via an edge to second slip.
In walked allrounder Higgins and combined with best mate Eskinanzi to offer resistance. The ask when they came together was 231, the same as it was overnight, but there was no real intention to score those runs.
The first boundary of the day - a six, no less - came 9.3 overs in when Higgins skipped down the track to lift Harmer over the mid on boundary. But even that was a retaliation to the loss of Eskinazi the over before. Porter, in the midst of a fine opening from the Pavilion End, eventually found a way past Eskinazi's bat and into his pad.
The breaching of the former Middlesex captain's defence was all part of the inevitability of Essex in these situations. As Harmer set his stall out at the Nursery End, and Cook took over from the Pavilion End after Porter's six-over burst of 1 for 9, it felt like the walls were closing in.
Higgins and Hollman pushed back, going beyond frustrating Harmer and Cook to score freely, particularly Hollman, who relished the battle with the South African offspinner. A perfect reverse sweep for four followed by a cut for a couple took the 22-year-old to 27, bringing up a 50-stand from just 79 deliveries.
By lunchtime, Snater and Ben Allison had taken over from Harmer and Cook respectively, and Middlesex's second-highest stand of the match had grown to 67. Now 146 behind, thoughts returned of where the hosts might have been had their top order not capitulated twice in 24 hours across days two and three.
The availability of a second new ball 11 overs into the afternoon session carried looming sense of dread from Middlesex's perspective. It manifested earlier than anticipated when, in the 77th over, Snater finally got the better of Higgins for the sixth lbw of the innings.
With the very next delivery, Middlesex skipper Toby Roland-Jones was squared up, edging sharply to first slip where Alastair Cook took a brilliant catch. Snater had two-in-two but had to wait until the next over to deliver the hat-trick ball.
He almost did not get the chance when No.11 Tim Murtagh plopped forward at the end of the first over of a new Harmer spell. Dan Lawrence missed a straightforward catch at silly point meaning Snater got his shot at three-in-three at Lord's. Hollman kept it out, then guided the next delivery over the slips for his sixth boundary of what was soon to become a fifth first-class century.
When the new ball was given to Snater, Hollman carved the first delivery through extra cover for four, then squirted out the fourth over cover to take Middlesex to 200. By that point, the final pair had already opted for the cavalier version of defiance, very much of the mind if they were going to go down, they would do so swinging. Murtagh tried to clear the Pavilion and ended up losing his off stump to the returning Porter.
It's worth noting Essex's impressive squad got stronger on Saturday with New Zealand seamer Doug Bracewell touching down in the UK. He comes in as a 10-game replacement for Australian Will Sutherland, who was ruled out with a lower back stress fracture.
Westley was unequivocal in his belief this is the strongest squad he has had at his disposal. Considering they finished fourth in 2022 and could have finished second had they beaten Lancashire in a Chelmsford crapshoot in the penultimate round, it is a stark warning to the rest.
"It was a massive disappointment," said Westley of the previous campaign. "That was my team talk to the guys in Northampton last year (after the last match of the season) and this is where we are as a club.
"And really, if we win that Lancs game, we finish second. And that's still a disappointment. We had times last year - at The Oval last year against Surrey - positions to go on and win the game. For whatever reason, we couldn't repeat what we did in the past.
"Fingers crossed, and it is one game, but if can play this brand and standard of cricket, I don't see why we can't go on right the way through."
