Whatever your views on plucking Moeen Ali out of Test retirement for the Ashes, we can all agree on one thing. It is one hell of a call.
A cricketer who polarised opinion throughout his initial seven years in the format is back for one last job. Arguably the biggest of the lot.
As soon as Jack Leach's back stress fracture was discovered, the pull of a mercurial off-spinning allrounder was too great for Ben Stokes, Brendon McCullum and Rob Key. Contact was made with Moeen on Sunday before news of Leach's injury was made public that evening, just over 24 hours after the conclusion of the Ireland Test at Lord's.
On a roster of precocious, recently-capped and reliable spin replacements, it was no surprise the free-wheeling vibe merchants opted for someone of their ilk. What you can say about selection during the Stokes-McCullum era is they have got every marginal call right, most recently with opting for Josh Tongue over Chris Woakes against Ireland. This, however, is top-tier bombastic, even by their standards.
The best of a 64-cap career - and, now, counting - featured glorious shot-making and magic deliveries among 2,914 runs and 195 wickets. Ahead of these five Tests against Australia, Moeen's experience, both time around the traps and pull on the soul, sets him above the rest.
It is no secret Stokes and others involved with this Test group are Moeen stans. He will fit into the dressing room culture seamlessly, still very much wired into the grander system of English cricket as Jos Buttler's vice-captain in the limited overs set-up. And there's something to be said for Stokes' powers of persuasion. It is less than a year ago that Moeen spurned advances to get him on the tour of Pakistan. He made a note of saying Test cricket is "hard work".
It is by no means an opinion unique to Moeen, which formed part of the remit for Stokes and McCullum when they first came into their positions. Their success in stripping away the rougher edges of the format - on and off the field - means the culture Moeen walks into is one far better suited to his mercurial ways.
This is no slight on previous regimes per se, but an important consideration in all this. For a player who has batted every position from opener to No.9, operated as the primary, secondary and tertiary spinner and was once "rested and rotated" out during the Covid-19 series against India at the beginning of 2021 after playing just one Test, role clarity would have been a key selling point in coaxing him back.
Stokes will likely do with Moeen as he has done with Leach: sorting his fields on his behalf, which included either constant tweaking or refusing requests for a sweeper. That made Leach a braver bowler, casting worry from his mind, which is unheard of from an English Test spinner since Graeme Swann. That Leach wore his unusually high average in Stokes's 13 Tests - 38.22 - as a badge of pride, alongside 45 wickets, speaks of a shift in mindset.
There is no question a peak Moeen would thrive in this environment, geared towards doing what they can to bring an individual's best to the fore. Whether with bat or ball, Moeen has always played the game like it was his duty to entertain, and when on song, there weren't many more enjoyable to watch. The question is, what does the best of this Moeen look like?
Well, who knows? The player himself certainly doesn't. In an interview with ESPNcricinfo a couple of months ago, Moeen admitted his bowling had dropped off in red-ball retirement. The bank of work was not what it once was, partly because he hadn't played a first-class match since his last Test cap against India in September 2021.
While the intervening period has been packed with white-ball glory, with two IPL titles for Chennai Super Kings sandwiching a T20 World Cup, his bowling has been sporadic at best, making any extrapolation broadly meaningless. He bowled twice in six matches at the World Cup, sending down a single over each time. In the recent IPL, he operated as one of CSK's supplementary slow bowling options, with most of his 26 overs coming in helpful conditions.
There are reasonable doubts about his durability, as much over the course of a Test as a series with five matches in seven weeks. Leach's endurance was a vital tool in an attack constantly pressing for wickets. His 515.1 overs under Stokes reflects the scale of his workload, and even if the role Moeen undertakes will not necessarily be with a focus on controlling the scoring, you do wonder about his multi-day stamina.
There is also Moeen's spinning finger, which has caused him trouble in the past. He tore it open on the 2017-18 tour of Australia leading to a grim return of five dismissals at an average of 115 across five Tests. It is also part of the reason he was dropped after the first Ashes Test in 2019.
Step back a bit and further quandaries emerge. Unless the next couple of months go spectacularly well, one imagines Moeen won't tour India for that Test series at the start of 2024. Part of his motivation for turning down a Test recall last year was due to a packed winter schedule. This one coming up is almost identical, with a 50-over World Cup followed by those now regular franchise commitments with the ILT20 and IPL. Will Jacks and Rehan Ahmed might also have an eye on that circuit too, given it has been made clear they are not as close as they think. All the more reason why the ECB have to ace their imminent revamp of central contracts and match fees.
Moeen has always been a choose-your-own adventure cricketer, and perhaps it is fitting he returns in such a choose-your-own argument fashion.
He averages 64.65 with the ball against Australia, but 33.28 against allcomers at home. He has been out of the game for too long, but long enough to feel refreshed. He could have been better under previous captains, but who knows how good he could be under this one?
He is not Mr Right, but he is Mr Right Now. He might flunk. He might thrive. It could be galling. It could be glorious.
What we know for certain is, should he get the nod at Edgbaston for the first Test, he won't be Jack Leach - he will be Moeen Ali. And we'll only know what that means when the Ashes are done.