Matthew Hayden believes that Australia need to make a change at the top of the order and give Cameron Green a license to play with freedom as opener in place of Marnus Labuschagne who is currently at No. 4.
Leading into the ODI World Cup it appeared Australia had moved on from pairing Labuschagne and Steven Smith together in the middle order, but when Labuschagne returned amid various injuries with some stunning innings in South Africa, followed by Travis Head's broken hand, he found himself at the tournament and in the XI.
So far, albeit from a small sample of three innings, Labuschagne has Australia's best average of 37.66 but is striking at just 64.57, which is in contrast to the form he brought into the competition when in eight matches against South Africa and India he had averaged 60.14 with a strike rate of 97.67, leading to praise from coach Andrew McDonald and national selector George Bailey for the increased tempo in his game.
"I don't think it does," Hayden told ESPNcricinfo when asked if pairing Smith and Labuschagne together works. "I don't think they'll change things either. To me, they have got a front anchor out and a back anchor out and the innings goes nowhere because they are both well and truly stable.
"It's fine to have one stabiliser, I think it's really important to have a mind like Steve Smith at the top of the order when you start to set totals or chase totals, you need that computer mind, but when you have two of them in a row I think it creates pressure through the top six so I'd make a change there."
Green was dropped following the opening game against India amid a period where he has struggled to find form with the bat, but Hayden argued that opening could free the shackles with Mitchell Marsh moving to No. 3 followed by Smith at four. Smith has always said No. 3, where he averages 52.60 in ODIs, is his preferred spot.
"Give him a licence, Cam Green at the top," he said. "To me, he's a kid who hasn't necessarily found his tempo in any format of the game but what we saw here during the IPL is that Mumbai Indians just sent him out and said, kid, just smash it.
"He's got huge levers, got great scoring abilities. Not so good when it comes to playing spin through the middle but by that stage if he's smashed Pakistan for 70 or 80, he's done his job.
"Mitch [Marsh] won't like to come down to three because he's had great success in his ODI career opening but soon enough you are going to get [Travis] Head back in there so ultimately Mitch is going to bat three, so make the change, create the initiative, do something different rather than sit and wait."
In a subsequent conversation on ESPNcricinfo's Match Day show between Hayden and India batter Cheteshwar Pujara, there was the suggestion that with the reality being that Labuschagne would be retained, he needed to be urged to play with more aggression.
"I still feel he has the ability to stabilise the innings," Pujara said. "We saw in the last game [against Sri Lanka], when Steve Smith got out he was the one who could anchor the innings. I would say, rather have a word with Marnus and if you feel like he needs to be a bit more positive then I think he has the experience of playing in Indian conditions and that's why I'd still prefer him ahead of Cameron Green."
Hayden added: "If you are going to pick Labuschagne, [say] you have a certain number of balls and our expectation is that you go for it, play a bit more proactively. It's not like anyone is doubting Labuschagne and the way he goes about his cricket, he's a terrific cricketer, no doubt about it, but it's a World Cup and you need to win key moments and for me, he's hoping he's getting runs rather than proactively getting them."
Australia are expected to go with an unchanged XI against Pakistan in Bengaluru and Travis Head is due to join the squad over the weekend as he continues to recover from the broken hand sustained in South Africa.