| Chicago Tigers | 1920 | 2-5-1 |
| Detroit Heralds | 1920 | 2-3-3 |
| Akron Pros/Indians | 1920-26 | 27-26-11 |
| Buffalo All-Americans/Bisons/Rangers | 1920-29 | 40-37-12 |
| Canton Bulldogs | 1920-26 | 38-19-11 |
| Cleveland Tigers/Indians | 1920-21 | 5-9-2 |
| Columbus Panhandles/Tigers | 1920-26 | 13-45-3 |
| Dayton Triangles | 1920-29 | 18-51-8 |
| Hammond Pros | 1920-26 | 7-28-4 |
| Muncie Flyers | 1920-21 | 0-3 |
| Rochester Jeffersons | 1920-25 | 8-27-4 |
| Rock Island Independents | 1920-25 | 26-14-12 |
| Cincinnati Celts | 1921 | 1-3 |
| Detroit Tigers | 1921 | 1-5-1 |
| New York Brickley Giants | 1921 | 0-2 |
| Tonawanda Kardex | 1921 | 0-1 |
| Washington Senators | 1921 | 1-2 |
| Evansville Crimson Giants | 1921-22 | 3-5 |
| Louisville Brecks/Colonels | 1921-26 | 1-12 |
| Minneapolis Marines/Red Jackets | 1921-24; 29-30 | 6-33-3 |
| Milwaukee Badgers | 1922-26 | 16-27-6 |
| Oorang Indians | 1922-23 | 4-16 |
| Racine Legion | 1922-24 | 14-11-6 |
| Toledo Maroons | 1922-23 | 8-5-4 |
| St. Louis All-Stars | 1923 | 1-4-2 |
| Cleveland Indians/Bulldogs | 1923-27 | 23-14-6 |
| Duluth Kelleys/Eskimos | 1923-27 | 16-20-3 |
| Kenosha Maroons | 1924 | 0-4-1 |
| Frankford Yellow Jackets | 1924-31 | 70-45-15 |
| Pottsville Maroons | 1925-28 | 27-20-2 |
| Detroit Panthers | 1925-26 | 12-8-4 |
| Kansas City Blues/Cowboys | 1924-26 | 12-15-1 |
| Providence Steam Rollers | 1925-31 | 41-32-11 |
| Brooklyn Lions | 1926 | 3-8 |
| Hartford Blues | 1926 | 3-7 |
| Los Angeles Buccaneers | 1926 | 6-3-1 |
| Racine Tornadoes | 1926 | 1-4 |
| New York Yankees | 1927-28 | 11-16-2 |
| Detroit Wolverines | 1928 | 7-2-1 |
| Boston Bulldogs | 1929 | 4-4 |
| Staten Island Stapletons | 1929-32 | 14-22-9 |
| Newark Tornadoes | 1930 | 1-10-1 |
| Brooklyn Dodgers | 1930-43 | 60-90-9 |
| Cleveland Indians | 1931 | 2-8 |
| Cincinnati Reds | 1933-34 | 3-14-1 |
| St. Louis Gunners | 1934 | 1-2 |
| Boston Yanks | 1944-48 | 14-38-3 |
| Miami Seahawks | 1946 | 3-11 |
| Brooklyn Dodgers | 1946-48 | 8-32-2 |
| Buffalo Bisons/Bills | 1946-49 | 23-26-5 |
| Chicago Hornets/Rockets | 1946-49 | 11-40-3 |
| Los Angeles Dons | 1946-49 | 25-27-2 |
| New York Yankees | 1946-49 | 35-17-2 |
| Baltimore Colts | 1947-50 | 11-40-1 |
| New York Bulldogs/Yanks | 1949-51 | 9-24-3 |
| Dallas Texans | 1952 | 1-11 |
