LINCOLN, Neb. -- For coach Ryan Day and his Ohio State Buckeyes, the dream of a College Football Playoff run is dead. The preseason No. 1 team in college football has lost four games and won't come anywhere close to contending for a national championship.
That brutal reality, sinking in just moments after a 31-28 upset loss at Nebraska, drove senior offensive lineman Carson Hinzman to tears Saturday.
"It's difficult to choke down a season like this, especially being a fifth-year senior," Hinzman said. "It just sucks, man. You give everything to a program and people and to come up short, it's heartbreaking."
Ohio State has dropped three of its past four games since losing quarterback Julian Sayin to a potentially season-ending injury to his throwing arm. But the trouble started once again on Saturday with a Buckeyes defense that struggled to get off the field throughout a Big Ten battle in the wind and rain.
"We're all disappointed in the outcome," Day said. "We're not going to win many games if we're giving up 31 points and only getting two stops in a whole game."
But that was nothing new for a unit led by defensive coordinator Matt Patricia, the former NFL coach who is the highest-paid coordinator in college football at $3.75 million.
The Buckeyes have allowed 30 or more points in each of their three Big Ten losses this season. All three losses came against teams that were not ranked in the AP Top 25. Nebraska and Oregon both bested Ohio State with offenses led by interim playcallers who took over for fired offensive coordinators.
"When you watch a game like this, you've got a lot of things that have to change," Day said. "I'm not going to jump to anything right now, because we have a game we've got to play in another week, but like always we've got to evaluate what's going on and we'll do that."
The frustrations for Day began in the first half as Nebraska's run-heavy approach took control with three consecutive touchdown drives to go ahead 21-7. The Huskers' Anthony Colandrea-led attack converted six times on third down and once on fourth down while keeping the Buckeyes' defense stuck on the field for more than 20 of the game's first 30 minutes.
When Nebraska pulled ahead again and made it 31-21 in the fourth quarter, Buckeyes freshman quarterback Luke Fahey responded by guiding a 75-yard touchdown drive and giving his team a chance with just under four minutes remaining.
But Patricia's defense could not get the ball back. Colandrea converted two third downs with his legs and put the game away by diving at the end of a third-and-5 conversion with one minute left.
"They hit us with a couple plays we'd seen throughout the game and weren't able to get off the field," Day said. "So, that was extremely frustrating. That ultimately cost us the game."
Huskers fans rushed the Memorial Stadium field and fireworks blasted off to celebrate the program's first victory over an AP Top 25 opponent since 2016. Nebraska's curse of 31 straight losses to ranked opponents was finally lifted. And Ohio State made some history of its own with its first four-loss season since 2011, the season before Urban Meyer arrived.
The Huskers leaned into their run game under interim OC Glenn Thomas with 45 rushes for 176 yards and a score. Colandrea was sacked just once, on the Huskers' opening drive, and consistently evaded pressure to convert in critical moments while throwing for 200 yards.
But Day was not interested in singling out his defensive line or any other position group that failed to play up to expectations on Saturday.
"For me to sit here and point out one group that came up short in this game would not be right because it took all of us to lose this game," he said. "But I think we all recognize the things that have come up short this year. I'm just as frustrated as anybody."
Up next is Michigan and another offense whose OC, Jason Beck, was already fired this season. How much faith and trust does Day have in Patricia to put together a successful game plan for the Buckeyes' hated rival?
"We don't have a choice," Day said. "We've got to get this thing together in the next week to go win this game. That's important. It's hard to be thinking about that right now coming off the field like this, disappointed and frustrated as we all are. We've got to figure it out. We've got to come up with a way. As always, at the end of the year, we'll evaluate everything and figure out what to do next."
Before Day can turns his focus to repairing the Buckeyes' problems, he'll have to close out a regular season that began with national title expectations against the struggling Wolverines, in a game with little on the line beyond rivalry pride.
"We've got to go beat the team up north and end on a good note," linebacker Payton Pierce said. "At the end of the day, you come to Ohio State to win that game, so that's all that matters."

















